Reservation
(609) 884-0505
Visit Us
3845 Bayshore Rd North Cape May, NJ 08204 United States
Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
50 piece Wings
seafood alfredo
seared scallop scampi
30 piece Wings
About
Italian Affair
Welcome to Italian Affair, where the heart of Italy meets the charm of North Cape May. Nestled at 3845 Bayshore Rd, this cozy eatery might just become your new favorite destination for authentic Italian cuisine, especially if you have a penchant for pizza.
At Italian Affair, you can indulge in a mouthwatering array of options. The focal point here is undoubtedly the giant 18" pizzas. From the classic Margherita Pizza to the indulgent Meat Lovers and unique Buffalo Chicken creations, you will find a perfect slice for every craving. Each pizza is crafted with precision, capturing that genuine New York-style experience which customers like Linda P. rave about.
But the offerings don't stop at pizza. The menu is a treasure trove of delectable entrees, from the savory Chicken Parmesan served with a side of pasta to the sumptuous Seared Scallop Scampi that’s a feast for the senses. The Crab Bisque, as highlighted by Julia F., is a must-try with its creamy texture and generous chunks of crab, elevating the dining experience to new heights.
Whether you're here for a family dinner, a casual outing, or a quick takeout, Italian Affair provides a warm and welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant ticks all the boxes with amenities such as
- Reservations
- Delivery and Takeout Services
- Outdoor Seating
- Vegetarian Options
- Catering for Groups
Notably, the restaurant accepts innovative payment methods, including cryptocurrency, making it not just a dining destination but a modern experience.
The essence of Italian Affair lies in its commitment to quality ingredients and customer satisfaction. As echoed by happy patrons like Zachary P., who pointed out the high quality and rapid service, this family-run business is all about delivering top-notch grub in a friendly environment.
So, whether you’re dining in, grabbing a pizza on the go, or exploring catering options for your next gathering, let Italian Affair take you on a delightful culinary journey through Italy right from North Cape May.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ We stumbled upon this place while doing some grocery shopping at Acme. So glad that we did! The restaurant itself is pretty small and seems to do mainly takeout orders. They do have tables available where you can eat in. We were greeted and seated right away. Our waitress was friendly and attentive throughout our time there. They have coolers that contain bottles and cans that you can choose from for your beverage. We ordered a large New York style pepperoni pizza half with peppers on it. It was absolutely delicious! It was cooked just right. The best pizza that I've had in a while. It also reheated well, which is always a plus. I recommend giving this place a try! ”
“ Our service was friendly and speedy for our lunch specials. The Plain NY style slices were delicious and crust thin like we love it. Some of the entrees looked pricey but sandwiches and pizza were good buys. The rear of the restaurant was closed for eating lunch but there was plenty of room for eat- in diners. The restrooms were very clean. ”
“ High quality, quick pace Excellent family run business serving up top notch grub. Love ordering from Italian Affair. ”
“ Ambiance- Dining area has definitely gotten a lot smaller over the years and the back are isn't quite as hidden as they'd probably like. I miss it being all open. Food- Consistently really good. The pizza delicious, meals large, the crab bisque is incredible! On the thicker side, which I like, with tons of crab pieces. Service- good. Friendly staff and quick take out. ”
“ We are from Houston and stopped here on our way to the Ferry. Glad we did! We ordered: Mozzarella sticks, Chicken parm dinner, chicken parm sub, Meatball sub, and 2 slices of cheese pizza. All was delish. But pizza was the best imo. ”
“ My grandmother wanted to try them out so we stopped in. It's definitely a small dining area, probably 5 tables max so they probably do a lot of take out. They had a pasta special for 2/$20 in the window. Penne A La Vodka was one of the items offered which is one of my fave dishes when I can find somewhere that offers it. Unfortunately they didn't have it on the regular menu and the employee running the register couldn't find a way to ring it up so that was kind of disappointing. I ordered a chicken Cheesesteak and my grandmother ordered a regular one. Another thing to note is that prices have increased slightly from the paper menus they have on the counter due to rising grocery cost. Not a deal breaker but our 2 Cheesesteaks and 2 cans of coke were $27 I think. The food came out nice and hot so that was a plus. I don't feel like they used much cheese in my Cheesesteak and it didn't seem to have much flavor so I ended up asking for ketchup to doctor it a bit. Also it just felt like it was missing something on the side; maybe a pickle spear, some chips, or fries? As I previously mentioned, the dining area is rather small and can get loud rather easily. The employees were talking in the back and you could hear every word. The lady that rang us up and brought the food out was nice enough but I don't think this is a return spot for me. I would probably rate them 3.5 stars. ”
